The extent of the impact of the Human Rights Act on different areas of law is often speculated upon, however, it may still come as a surprise to some that the Act has an impact on issues of comparative advertising. The High Court in two recent decisions considered the impact of the Human Rights Act in deciding that it was not prepared to grant an injunction to prevent publication of this type of advertising. The Court concluded that the Act applied to comparative advertising and for it to grant an injunction where a human right may be affected, it must be satisfied £that the applicant is likely to establish that publication should not be allowed.£ This is slightly more stringent than the usual test, which is whether a £real prospect of success£ is shown.
Further, it was stated in Apollo that the opinion expressed by Jacob LJ in the Court of Appeal decision in O2 Holdings Ltd & another v Hutchison 3G Ltd, that use of a trade mark in comparative advertising is not £use£ for the purposes of trade mark infringement under sections 10(1) and 10(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1994, is not law. However, in the absence of any decision from the ECJ as to the application of these sections to comparative advertising, the claimant was not able to establish that was is £likely£ to succeed at trial.
These cases will make it considerably more difficult to obtain interim injunctions in comparative advertising cases.
This article first appeared in Law-Now, CMS Cameron McKenna's free online information service, and has been reproduced with their permission. For more information about Law-Now, please go to www.law-now.com. Contact Law-Now administrator law-now.administrator@cms-cmck.com Tel: 44 (0)20 7367 2106 Fax: 44 (0)20 7367 2000 CMS Cameron McKenna LLP Mitre House 160 Aldersgate Street, London EC1A 4DD www.law-now.com Copyright (C) 2005-7 CMS Cameron McKenna LLP. All rights reserved. Information may be shared; however, reproduction in any medium requires our permission.
Legal Day Table
Jobs Now
LEGAL DIRECTOR Sought for challenging in-house position with Myspace, the online space which has revolutionized the way people interact, as sole attorney in their London office More >>
HEALTHCARE LAWYER With at least 5 years PQE sought by Capsticks, a leading healthcare practice, to drive forward the development of their Birmigham based office More >>
PI PARALEGAL Required by Plexus Law, a specialist PI firm, to provide in-house support to the Motor Claims Department in their Folkstone offices More >>
NETWORK ENGINEER Sought by Personnel 2000 for their client, an international banking insurance provider, based in the Cayman Islands More >>
LEGAL SECRETARY Required by Law Choice for their client, a prestigious US law firm, to work for 2 partners in their Dubai offices More >>
